Wow...Well when I first look at this I see amazing. This is just an absolutely wonderful piece of art!! I love the colours of the tiger and the colours of scar. The fire around them is really lovely and it looks amazing. I think you did an amazing job on this! Just absolutely one of the best lion king and another character art I have seen!! You are REALLY a great artist!
Something I would improve though is Scar's paws, they are a little big and I think they distract some people from what a wonderful piece this is! Thats the only thing I would change, otherwise this is just wonderful!!
It's a myth that tigers are so much larger and stronger than lions that they could easily win any fight, but apparently a really popular myth on the Internet. (Even on those wildlife videos on YouTube, there seems to be a rather large "lion-hater tiger-lover" community. What on earth is that about?)
Anyway, Scar may look really skinny and all, but in the fight with Simba he was actually winning, right until Simba was able to pull off a lucky judo move of some sort to throw him from the cliff.
My money's on Shere Khan. Scar, as much as I love him, is stupid enough to make the first move and give Shere Khan the right moment to strike. Shere Khans a sneaky bastard. Haha. But this is really good!!
Scar doesn't really have the brute strength, he couldn't even just kill mufasa he had get the hyenas to start a stamped to kill him. Shere khan would win, he may not be as smart but he's stronger. Please some one comment against this I still want a reason that scar would win, I'm a curious person